We are sure about Lord Krishna. The movie and TV representations give him a very clear persona. We know that he has playful disposition. He's cheerful, has a great sense of humour, speaks with a glint in his eyes, is a hit with women and is quick on the retort. He's Giridhar "naagar" (nagar-wala), meaning he's a city-bred: suave and sophisticated. Yes, he did spend his childhood in the cowbelt but moved on so that we can actually maintain a conversation with him outside the topics of agriculture and animal husbandry. His mannerisms are of course legendary: left arm bent at the elbow and elegantly resting on his waist, right arm twirled over his flowing silk upper cloth.
When he laughs, it is a good, hearty one with the head thrown back ever so slightly and with a visible rock of the shoulders. If at all there is a confusion, there's just one: Does he have blue talcum powder all over his body and crimson lipstick a la N.T.Ramarao or does his skin look just like the rest of us the way Nitish Bharadwaj looked ? In short, he is just the celebrity (if I can take the liberty of saying that) whom we would swoon over, feel weak in the knees, flock to get a glimpse, shake his hand and get his autograph. He is your proverbial rock-star!
Lord Shiva is rightfully miffed. He is a victim of bad representation and bad marketing. Firstly, TV serials give him no good roles. He has been reduced to a side-kick who gets his two minutes of fame (that too in the background) in a three hour movie. If at all he gets a chance, he is made to stand behind cardboard cut-outs of fleecy, white clouds with very little scope for improvization. Often, the comedian who plays Narada in the serial also doubles up to play the role of Shiva which again doesn't improve Shiva's self-image.
Secondly, the renowned artiste Ravi Varma (with due respect to him) has complicated matters by painting Shiva with a moustache. We are thoroughly confused. Does Shiva sport a moustache or is he clean shaven ? We are simply not used to someone who can show up either way. That's a no-no! It happens only in movies where the hero has a double role, one good and another bad.
Another problem with Shiva's TV avatars is that he is forced to wear the most hideous of outfits. Either the TV artiste has to get used to a real snake trying to strangulate his neck so that he is forever distracted or he is forced to look comical by having a rubber imitation.
Shiva's minions (ganas) add to the complication. On TV, they need to select the most outsized human beings to play this role. He'll wear a long skirt, a pot belly to rival a ghatam, a well endowed drooping moustache, canine teeth and horns to complete the equation.
To top it, folks to the north of the Vindhyas swear that Shiva likes "bhang" and thus keep him perenially drowzy and doped.
All said and done, Shiva has been reduced to a caricature who could scarcely inspire anybody to look up to him. It seems as if there is a well hatched out global conspiracy to cut him to size and malign him to show some others in better light! Now, don't for a moment think that this is the truth. All that you have to do is to leave the world of TV, comics and paintings and look at the sculpture of yesteryears.
Watch Mahadeva in all his grandeur at the Elephanta caves, at the Kailas temple at Ellora, the Chalukya motifs at Badami and the Chola bronzes. It is here that Shiva stands out unparalleled in representation. Sculpture has been able to capture the sublime mystique where other art forms miserably fail.
Can someone take the idea from these sculptures and come up with a persona for our TV and drama shows which can do justice to Lord Shiva ? Shiva clearly needs a makeover.
When he laughs, it is a good, hearty one with the head thrown back ever so slightly and with a visible rock of the shoulders. If at all there is a confusion, there's just one: Does he have blue talcum powder all over his body and crimson lipstick a la N.T.Ramarao or does his skin look just like the rest of us the way Nitish Bharadwaj looked ? In short, he is just the celebrity (if I can take the liberty of saying that) whom we would swoon over, feel weak in the knees, flock to get a glimpse, shake his hand and get his autograph. He is your proverbial rock-star!
Lord Shiva is rightfully miffed. He is a victim of bad representation and bad marketing. Firstly, TV serials give him no good roles. He has been reduced to a side-kick who gets his two minutes of fame (that too in the background) in a three hour movie. If at all he gets a chance, he is made to stand behind cardboard cut-outs of fleecy, white clouds with very little scope for improvization. Often, the comedian who plays Narada in the serial also doubles up to play the role of Shiva which again doesn't improve Shiva's self-image.
Secondly, the renowned artiste Ravi Varma (with due respect to him) has complicated matters by painting Shiva with a moustache. We are thoroughly confused. Does Shiva sport a moustache or is he clean shaven ? We are simply not used to someone who can show up either way. That's a no-no! It happens only in movies where the hero has a double role, one good and another bad.
Another problem with Shiva's TV avatars is that he is forced to wear the most hideous of outfits. Either the TV artiste has to get used to a real snake trying to strangulate his neck so that he is forever distracted or he is forced to look comical by having a rubber imitation.
Shiva's minions (ganas) add to the complication. On TV, they need to select the most outsized human beings to play this role. He'll wear a long skirt, a pot belly to rival a ghatam, a well endowed drooping moustache, canine teeth and horns to complete the equation.
To top it, folks to the north of the Vindhyas swear that Shiva likes "bhang" and thus keep him perenially drowzy and doped.
All said and done, Shiva has been reduced to a caricature who could scarcely inspire anybody to look up to him. It seems as if there is a well hatched out global conspiracy to cut him to size and malign him to show some others in better light! Now, don't for a moment think that this is the truth. All that you have to do is to leave the world of TV, comics and paintings and look at the sculpture of yesteryears.
Watch Mahadeva in all his grandeur at the Elephanta caves, at the Kailas temple at Ellora, the Chalukya motifs at Badami and the Chola bronzes. It is here that Shiva stands out unparalleled in representation. Sculpture has been able to capture the sublime mystique where other art forms miserably fail.
Can someone take the idea from these sculptures and come up with a persona for our TV and drama shows which can do justice to Lord Shiva ? Shiva clearly needs a makeover.
Complete make-over for Shiva needed, starting from his wardrobe (can't he wear anything other than a skimpy tiger skin???). Btw, you didn't mention about the only good portrayal of the lord in ThiruviLayaadal though!!
ReplyDeleteUsha, Totally agree with you. If there is a cinematic portrayal of Shiva which is an absolute stand out, it has to be the Tamil film Thiruvilaiyadal. Sivaji Ganesan as Shiva has a moustache and a beard as well. Manages to pull off a stellar performance which is captivating even when we watch it today. One thing to note though is that this Shiva is dressed in a non traditional way. He turns up with royal robes and only from the context can we actually figure out that it's Shiva.
ReplyDeleteSivaji is cut out for these roles. His body language is too good for mythological films. Of course, we also had the dramatist R.S Manohar. His "Shiva thandava" play used to be awesome with some breath-taking trick shots on stage. I'm planning to cover Manohar's plays in a different essay.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteShankar, I am pretty sure that you did not watch OM NAMAH SHIVAYA on star utsav. I personally like shiva's outfit. He may not be the Rock star but surely a jolly good fellow to be a companion for dum maro dum at any time of the day. Also He may not be a great flirt, but surely has a way with the ‘kumari’s even at a relatively older age.
ReplyDeleteDid you know he created a huge scene during his marriage with Parvati. His loin cloth (an exquisite exhibition of tiger fur) was held tight by the snakes. While ushering the wedding chamber, accidentally he came close to Vishnu who had Gadura next to him. Seeing Gadura so close by, all the snakes fled and ... and he became the ladies' man..
Pranabesh, You are right. I haven't watched the serial Om namah Shivaya.Your observations are funny. No comments!
ReplyDelete